Thanksgiving Dessert Ideas

Thanksgiving is a holiday that celebrates gratitude, family, and tradition by bringing people together to enjoy a variety of comforting foods with those we love. While the first thing that comes to mind for many is the main course, with turkey, mashed potatoes, and stuffing, the real star of the show is dessert. From warm pies to trifles and cakes, even the fullest dinner guests will make room for a sweet treat to conclude the evening.

Classics such as pumpkin, apple, and pecan pie bring comfort and familiarity, while cakes and tarts add a twist on seasonal flavors. However, it’s not just the foods, but the love behind them that makes them matter the most. Whether it's a new recipe or a twist on a family tradition, the joy of sharing and giving to the people who matter most is the cherry on top of a perfect holiday! Below are some easy Thanksgiving dessert ideas that are sure to give your dinner guests something to look forward to.

Pumpkin Cookie Sandwich (Gluten-Free Option)

Photo by Scientifically Sweet

Make a yummy handheld dessert this Thanksgiving with an easy pumpkin cookie recipe that can be paired with Andia’s Ice Cream flavors of your choice. Or opt for a gluten-free version here. Whether you serve the cookies on the side of ice cream or as an ice cream sandwich, the warm spiced chewiness of the cookies is the perfect complement for the cold sweetness of our delicious ice creams!

Apple Pie + Ice Cream

Photo by Little Spoon Farm

Take your classic apple pie to the next level by pairing it with Andia’s French Vanilla ice cream. Watch as the warm apple syrup blends with the cool vanilla ice cream to give you a mouthwatering flavor combination. This simple pair will take the traditional apple pie and make it into the perfect way to end your day!

Andia’s Ice Cream Pie

Photo by Andia's Ice Cream

Start a new family tradition with Andia’s Ice Cream Pies! Our pies combine familiar seasonal flavors with ice cream on a delicious graham crust to supply you with an easy Thanksgiving dessert idea. Ice Cream pies are released on our website & Goldbelly every year for pre-order, where you can start planning the perfect dessert for you and your family this holiday season!

Be the first to know when our 2025 pies are announced by subscribing to our newsletter!

Pumpkin Pie Milkshake

Photo by The Slow Roasted Italian

Don’t feel like making a pie? Don’t stress! Get the same flavors you love with a pumpkin pie milkshake. Substitute Andia’s French Vanilla or Pumpkin flavors, depending on personal preference, to further enhance your drinks! The perfect option for a light dessert, and can continue to be made throughout the holiday season.

Andia’s French Vanilla Ice Cream is at all of our locations, which can be found here, or for pickup here!

Andia’s Chocolate Pudding / Mud Cups

Photo by Andia's Ice Cream

Andia’s Mud Cups recipe is perfect for an interactive and easy Thanksgiving dessert you can make with kids! Made by our founder and CEO, Andia Xouris, this recipe combines one of our delicious flavors with a fun twist. Substitute the gummy worms for marshmallows or candy pumpkins for a more fall-themed treat, or keep the recipe as is and have fun making and eating this delicious layered dessert!

Caramel Apple Cider Float

Photo by Mel's Kitchen Cafe

Add a twist on the classic fall drink and make an apple cider float to satisfy your sweet tooth! Use Andia’s French Vanilla flavor to elevate your cider with this easy and delicious Thanksgiving recipe. Finish it off with a caramel drizzle of your choice and serve to your dinner guests who might not be up for a large dessert after dinner!

Andia’s French Vanilla Ice Cream is at all of our locations, which can be found here, or for pickup here.

For more menu information and recipe ideas, be sure to follow us on Instagram here & subscribe to our newsletter here.